The I17 with the aluminum mast is not being sold anymore I think.
Actually this version appears to be still offered in Europe.
http://www.nacraeurope.com/nacra17.php
The "F17" has a taller carbon mast and is cheaper than an A3.
This in itself is true but that is because the last time I checked the European prices the A2 was the most expensive A-cat ever and that included the Marstrom A-cats.
The I17-R or F17 was offered to somebody I know at 17.850 Euro's, that is more expensive then "The Tool A-cat" and the Boyer A-cats used to go for.
Maybe things changed in the last 12 months but I doubt it.
I think that the F17 would be a better class to get into since it isn't an arms race like the A class is. You won't have to worry about having the latest boat since it is a 1 design(manufacturer) class.
Normally you would have a point but since there have been no less then 6 different versions of the Inter-17 in the 9 years since its inception, your statement is totally bogus They are and have been :
Aus I-17, EU I-17, US I-17R, EU I-17XL, US F17 and now the new EU I-17
And all these versions have been sufficiently different to have significantly different ratings.
The European Texel rating already lists 3 different Inter-17 singlehanders at ;
Nacra Inter 17 109
nacra Inter 17 Xl 107
Nacra Inter 17 R 102
This doesn't include the new EU I-17 yet of which the dealor claims that is has a larger spinnaker and apparently 15 kg less weight.
Source :
http://www.watersportverbond.nl/data/Z8F_numdet-01-4-02-2007.pdfand
http://www.nacraeurope.com/nacra17.phpAt least in the A-cat class older design still are somewhat competitive. If you had bought a EU I-17 say 3 years ago then today you will be chanceless against the I-17R or the new I-17. 2 sq. mtr. more sailarea and a spinnaker that is also 2 sq. mtr. larger makes sure of that.
In fact I would turn the argument around. If someone is worried about the need to having the latest version of a boat he would be far better off in the A-cat class then the I-17 class. The fact that some dealors call thier own classes One-Design classes doesn't mean they actually are on. Together with the Hobie Tiger the Inter-17 is the counterexample against such claims.
Also, the addition of a spinnaker will double your fun especially in light air.
That is something I agree upon with you Dave.
Wouter