Quote

I didn't say 'take the jib off' I said 'move that same sail area to the main'



Then you answer this :

-1- What is preventing me from adding a jib in addition to moving all that sail area into the mainsail ?

-2- Why are the most succesful catamaran classes like the F18's and Hobie 16's not uni-rigs ?

-3- Why do all modern boats have spinnakers when obviously putting all that spinnaker area in the mainsail is more efficient ?

-4- Why aren't all A-cats using the C-class solid wing sails ?

-5- Why has the A-cat class actively banned full foiling ?

-6- Why aren't the A-cat using spinnakers ?

-7- Ergo why is the A-cat class the way it is ?


I'm guessing your answer to all these questions is :"Because area in the mainsail is more efficient"

My answer is "Because the A-cat class members have written the rules such as to actively encourage the way the A-cats are designed now." Sometimes they have done because that is faster, sometimes they did it for wholely different reasons."

Ergo, looking at the A-cats is not always proof that something is better or more performant.

Wouter

Last edited by Wouter; 11/12/07 11:25 AM.

Wouter Hijink
Formula 16 NED 243 (one-off; homebuild)
The Netherlands