BK,
Contact anyone with a destroyed mast (aluminum or carbon) and cut it into 3 inch segments to be mounted on a wood base and engraved with the series information.
You can even paint designs on them like Tami said.
That's the coolest trophy I have - Ryan's mast section broken at Tradewinds. They used it for one of the Clearwater regattas.
The next coolest one is the Endurance series glass one (although the base keeps falling off - it's not toddler-proofed)
And for "brag flags", if someone had a destroyed sail, you could cut that into pennants, right?
A little elbow grease and some creativity, and you've got a slew of awards for cheap, cheap, cheap! And they're unique. Hagar is definitely ahead of the curve...