| Re: New weight categories, effective now.
[Re: John Williams]
#252645 09/24/12 01:19 PM 09/24/12 01:19 PM |
Joined: Aug 2006 Posts: 297 rexdenton
enthusiast
|
enthusiast
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 297 | Or you could sail a bit in the class at a variety of weights on several platforms and in a variety of conditions and venues with a variety of skippers and begin to draw some conclusions. That's more fun, IMO.  Rex, You seem to have already decided that light teams have an unfair advantage. If you have the inclination, I'm happy to email you the regatta report from the measurer (Excel format) and the complete Sailwave file, from which you can glean the recorded wind speeds. However, it would be pretty easy to poke holes in any analysis - second-row starts, sea state, fouls and cluttered gates, older v newer sails... the variables are endless, really. I don't have a driving need to persuade you (or anyone else) to agree with my conclusion. The discussion actually makes for good bar-room debriefs. ps - your edited post is much more conversational. Thanks for taking the edge off. Well I actively try to take the edge off, but when challenged with a BS conclusion, I am paid handsomely and am given latitude to be far less diplomatic with numbers and conclusions with people holding advanced degrees in medicine and biology... I'd gladly take that data and work on it in my spare time for an unbiased opinion. We are not very good, but at a combined weight of 400+ lbs (...to qualify that, my 19 yo nationally ranked swimming/triathlon champion son and I wear the exact ame sized clothes...), I do question whether heavy teams can be competitive in light air on the F18. Evidence of that remains anecdotal until tested. I wouldn't say it is a conclusion, but I have spoken with 4 experienced heavier teams that feel the rules are geared toward success of teams at the light end of the range. Knowing the relationship is a benefit to the competition of the class, as it will drive enforcement of such things as the oft ignored weigh-ins, and the minimum wind speed criteria for events.
Last edited by rexdenton; 09/24/12 01:22 PM.
Nacra F18 #856
| | |
Entire Thread
|
New weight categories, effective now.
| John Williams | 07/21/10 08:24 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| David Ingram | 07/21/10 08:43 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| John Williams | 07/21/10 09:18 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| TEAMVMG | 07/22/10 05:47 AM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| Tony_F18 | 07/22/10 07:36 AM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| CatSailingHu | 07/22/10 01:24 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| John Williams | 07/22/10 02:11 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rhodysail | 11/06/10 07:09 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| pinax | 11/12/10 09:28 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| pinax | 11/13/10 12:22 AM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| Dlennard | 11/13/10 12:30 AM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| John Williams | 11/13/10 01:47 AM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| pinax | 11/13/10 04:34 AM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| John Williams | 08/22/12 04:20 AM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| FDUB flyers | 08/29/12 12:54 AM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rhodysail | 09/20/12 04:52 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rexdenton | 09/21/12 03:32 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rexdenton | 09/22/12 12:02 AM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| John Williams | 09/20/12 09:52 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rhodysail | 09/25/12 12:47 AM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| Baltic | 09/22/12 03:36 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| F-18 5150 | 09/22/12 04:48 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| dr5e14w | 09/23/12 04:31 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| John Williams | 09/22/12 10:07 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| John Williams | 09/23/12 06:57 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rexdenton | 09/24/12 05:28 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| John Williams | 09/24/12 05:47 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rexdenton | 09/24/12 06:19 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rhodysail | 09/25/12 01:07 AM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| mini | 09/25/12 01:17 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| David Ingram | 09/25/12 02:22 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| mini | 09/26/12 12:22 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rexdenton | 09/26/12 01:47 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rexdenton | 09/26/12 02:17 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| waterbug_wpb | 09/27/12 02:59 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| Jeff.Dusek | 09/23/12 11:47 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| John Williams | 09/24/12 05:55 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| Jeff.Dusek | 09/24/12 07:57 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| Karl_Brogger | 09/24/12 06:22 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rexdenton | 09/24/12 06:43 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| John Williams | 09/24/12 07:06 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rexdenton | 09/24/12 09:52 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| Jeff.Dusek | 09/26/12 03:52 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rexdenton | 09/26/12 06:19 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| macca | 09/26/12 04:20 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| rehmbo | 09/27/12 01:37 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| samc99us | 10/08/12 02:41 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| ksurfer2 | 10/08/12 03:39 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| waterbug_wpb | 10/08/12 04:29 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| David Ingram | 10/08/12 04:56 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| Tony_F18 | 10/08/12 05:16 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| David Ingram | 10/08/12 05:25 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| waterbug_wpb | 10/08/12 05:51 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| Team_Cat_Fever | 10/11/12 03:23 PM |
Re: New weight categories, effective now.
| Tony_F18 | 10/11/12 04:05 PM | |
|
0 registered members (),
212
guests, and 33
spiders. | Key: Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod | | Forums26 Topics22,406 Posts267,061 Members8,150 | Most Online2,167 Dec 19th, 2022 | | |