Hello Dirk,

Actually because you rounding off the numbers 33 from 33.333333 etc you still get a difference in righting moment when indeed they should be exactly the same.

It would have been smarted to use a=b=c= 40 for the tri and a=b=c=60 fro the cat. Now you don't have any rounding off effects that produces inequalities were there are none.

In effect :

________
a....b....c

weights a=b=c=40 with width=3
total weight = 120
righting = 1.5*40+3*40= 180

________
a.........b
Weights a=b=60 with width l=3
total weight = 120
3*60 = 180


But your example does show nicely why there can't be a difference in righting moment between a cat and a tri when both share the same overall weight and overall width.

Wouter


Wouter Hijink
Formula 16 NED 243 (one-off; homebuild)
The Netherlands