Here's my trusty 12yr old Toyota Hiace. The Cats behind are worth thousands more. The A on top of the F16 belongs to my friend who is in the picture below (left unfortunately) but I thought you might like the link between the photo's.
MP*MULTIHULLS
-- Have You Seen This? --
Re: What do you tow with
[Re: bvining]
#88725 11/11/0611:56 AM11/11/0611:56 AM
Anybody tow with a sports car? Any 2 seater/ragtops?
What about a Miata? <img src="http://www.catsailor.com/forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif" alt="" />
Just for the information of those who are comparing, American Gallons are smaller than Imperial (British/Canadian). Here is the conversion. 1 imperial gal = 1.2009 U S gals = 4.5446 Litres 1 USG = .8327 Imp. Gal = 3.7843 L. 10 Litres = 2.6425 USG = 2.2004 Imp. Gal.
SO, my questions are: (1) When towing, is it easier on your vehicle if you have manual transmission or automatic?
Auto trannys have become a very good at power transfer so there is very little difference. I still prefer a manual as I’m an old guy who learned with one.
Quote
(2) What causes the decrease in mpg when you are towing? Is it the actual amount of weight on the trailer? I would think that once inertia kicks in at steady highway speeds on flat roads, the trailer would be irrelevant (but apparently NOT).
(3) Or is it the windage (drag) of the trailer and boats that brings down the mpg?
It’s a combination of the two. Inertia will be overcome by drag and wheel friction.
Quote
(4) Or does it have something to do with the size of the trailer wheels vis-a-vis the size of the vehicle wheels?
There’s a number of things to consider when looking at wheels. The larger the wheel diameter, the more energy to get it spinning. There’s also bearing and road friction. One thing that would reduce drag would be to make the tire and rim narrower but the trade off would be weight capacity.
US Sail Level 2 Instructor US Sail Level 3 Coach
Re: What do you tow with
[Re: Mark P]
#88727 11/11/0612:13 PM11/11/0612:13 PM
There’s a number of things to consider when looking at wheels. The larger the wheel diameter, the more energy to get it spinning. There’s also bearing and road friction. One thing that would reduce drag would be to make the tire and rim narrower but the trade off would be weight capacity.
Wow, I never thought about that before, but I guess that's why the tires on horse-racing sulkies are very skinny -- and on racing bicycles. * * * * * As far as wind drag, has anybody ever come up with a way to make the rig more aerodynamic for trailering?
Re: What do you tow with
[Re: Mary]
#88730 11/11/0601:23 PM11/11/0601:23 PM
Wow, I never thought about that before, but I guess that's why the tires on horse-racing sulkies are very skinny -- and on racing bicycles. * * * * * As far as wind drag, has anybody ever come up with a way to make the rig more aerodynamic for trailering?
Some road bikes use tires that are only 18 cm across. Really skinny but they still have to carry the same weight of the rider and bike so they may bulge out more where the tire contacts the road.
1998 Dodge Ram 1500, 5.2 V8, 5 spd manual, K&N filter w/ cat back exhaust. The things got 210,000 miles on and gets 16-17 mpg whether its pulling a cat or not.
Same, but 4x4, only 132,000 mi and no kids. Also, AirRaid instead of K&N.
My skipper should win for worst MPG's. He tows with a GMC motor home. It gets about 7MPG but sure makes the "camping" better. <img src="http://www.catsailor.com/forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" />
Joanna
Blade F16 "Too Sharp to Touch"
Re: What do you tow with
[Re: Mary]
#88735 11/11/0606:08 PM11/11/0606:08 PM
Ok...after towing double stacked N20's today for the first time, I'll chime in...because I think I should get a couple of awards.... I drive a Black 2003 GMC Sierra Denali with a 6.0 litre V8, AWD, and Quadrasteer (yes all four wheels turn). I love my truck for a lot of reasons...it just "goes" anywhere I want in any conditions, and does so with comfort and class....only one (major) flaw....you'll read in a moment. Sooo....IMHO...we're WAY up there on the "Cool" factor!! Picture (sorry I don't have one to share at the moment!) 2 gorgeous Nacra 20's stacked and flyin' down the hiway behind a beautiful shiny black truck that stands out against most other trucks all on it's own to begin with!!!
Now...for the bad part.....and all my Euro friends can get their rocks ready to throw!!! I definitely get the gas guzzler award. Normal (non-towing) MPG is 12.7 city/hiway combined 50/50, doing 85 on the hiway. Towing a single boat at 75 on the hiway...11.7. Now for the really bad news.....(Do the Euro's and Aussies have rocks ready with arms ****??)...Double stacked and only 65MPH down the hiway....a whopping 9.3MPG!!! And I'm starting a 1000 mile trip to Florida Monday!
I think I either need to buy an oil well...or start looking for a "less cool" tow vehicle!!
JL (dodging the stones from across the pond!!)
JL
N20 # 1041 "Lucille"
A-cat USA 44
Re: What do you tow with
[Re: JoeLeonard]
#88736 11/11/0608:47 PM11/11/0608:47 PM
Joe, I even get better than that with a 35' RV weighing 19,500 lbs and pulling a double stack. I got around 9.5 mph on the trip up to the F18 Na's driving around 70mph. On the flat lands I can get 10 to 12 mph and better if going slower. My F250 gets around 15 to 17 towing at 70 mph.
I have a Honda Odyssey (minivan, with automatic transmission). It gets 29-30 mpg on the highway with no trailer.
Every year I end up pulling a trailer loaded with boats from Key Largo to Ohio, over the mountains. With two Hobie Waves double-stacked (and a couple sets of beach wheels) the mileage goes down to about 23 mpg.
SO, my questions are: (1) When towing, is it easier on your vehicle if you have manual transmission or automatic?
Depends on the car. If it is underpowered for the load and constantly changing between the top two gears, a manual in 2nd top gear is probably the go. Holding an auto in 2nd top and making sure it has a cooler attached should be fine but don't run it at top speed for hours on end.
Quote
(2) What causes the decrease in mpg when you are towing? Is it the actual amount of weight on the trailer? I would think that once inertia kicks in at steady highway speeds on flat roads, the trailer would be irrelevant (but apparently NOT).
(3) Or is it the windage (drag) of the trailer and boats that brings down the mpg?
Whilst you are accelerating most you are fighting the weight at lower speeds and a combination as it increases. When you are cruising, it's mostly windage that is the problem. You are in effect driving with a big parachute out the back of your car.
Quote
(4) Or does it have something to do with the size of the trailer wheels vis-a-vis the size of the vehicle wheels?
Not with regard to MPG. I do like the idea of larger trailer wheels though. A 15" wheel will do far less RPM than a 11" wheel and thus your wheel bearings and tyres etc etc will give far less trouble.
Tiger Mike
Re: What do you tow with
[Re: hobie1616]
#88739 11/12/0602:06 AM11/12/0602:06 AM
(4) Or does it have something to do with the size of the trailer wheels vis-a-vis the size of the vehicle wheels?
There’s a number of things to consider when looking at wheels. The larger the wheel diameter, the more energy to get it spinning. There’s also bearing and road friction. One thing that would reduce drag would be to make the tire and rim narrower but the trade off would be weight capacity. [/quote]
IMHO the friction from larger dia wheel/tyre combo on a boat trailer would be virtually nil compared to that of overall wind-drag at 40+ mph. I think it would be a no-brainer in most cases.
Tiger Mike
Re: What do you tow with
[Re: C2 Mike]
#88740 11/12/0602:55 AM11/12/0602:55 AM
My old tow vehicle..... Vintage Sports Car I guess
1977 Ford XC Fairmont GXL Coupe
Engine 351 ci Cleveland 2V Close chamber heads 4V Exhaust Valves 2V inlet Valves
Fuel Methanol Custom Nitro Methane Injection
Drive Line Gear Box - Top Loader Diff - 9 inch with 3.5 gears 4 wheel disc breaks 13 inch x 15 inch rear wheels (12 slot rims) 11 inch x 14 inch Front wheels (12 slot rims not pictured here)
Factory wind back sun roof.
Re: What do you tow with
[Re: Mary]
#88742 11/12/0610:08 AM11/12/0610:08 AM
When towing, is it easier on your vehicle if you have manual transmission or automatic?
Towing is easier on a manual tansmission. Most or some (well especially older vehicles) automatics will have a tendancy to shift in and out of overdrive more often than normal during towing, due to the additional drag and weight of the boat and trailer. Except in the case of larger vehicles with huge towing capacities, this heats up the transmission fluid more than normal operation. Check your owners manual for recommended towing practices. Some will suggest turning the overdride off (if function is available) or keeping the transmission selector in the next to highest gear (3 or 4). In either case this is preventing the transmission from making more frequent shifts.
A transmission cooler may be added by any competent mechanic and are available at all chain auto parts stores. The transmission fluid lines are routed to the front of the vehicle for cooling anyway making it a fairly easy modification that should cost less than $200. If you feel your vehicled is overworked, it's a fairly inexpensive insurance policy to have. Or, have your transmission serviced at the "Heavy use" interavals. Personaly we change the fluid more often.
Since the old days and "sport" vehivles were brought up...
Had great fun towing the spanking new '81 H16 with our '67 Camaro, 327ci/275hp. Wish we still had that little rascal. <img src="http://www.catsailor.com/forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif" alt="" />
John H16, H14
Re: What do you tow with
[Re: gree2056]
#88743 11/12/0612:33 PM11/12/0612:33 PM