| Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: Rolf_Nilsen]
#99130 02/20/07 08:33 PM 02/20/07 08:33 PM |
Joined: Jun 2001 Posts: 3,116 Annapolis, MD Mark Schneider
Carpal Tunnel
|
Carpal Tunnel
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 3,116 Annapolis, MD | Physics is physics... You only get so much horsepower out of the rig and you have to move a fixed amount of mass in the boat PLUS the team on the boat. Skill matters but you can't violate the laws of the universe. Design allows you to depower effectively.. (good for the small guys) Design gives you max horsepower available. (good for the small guys... bad for the big guys who need more horsepower) Obviously, they have now maxed out the power of the rig and sail plan. The T Class has strictly enforced their 5 knot minimum windspeed rule. Protests are filed if the PRO tries to cheat.. Since the teams at the elite level all clustered around the optimal weight for most championship conditions... the class thought the competition was fair (without a weight minimum). Now in China... the 5 knot rule is off... If the flag on the beach even moves.. they start and race. So...The only way to rebalance the equation is with a min weight rule. Since the only game that matters for the next two years is China... they have to find a way to reestablish a competitive playing field. What is the problem? The min weight rule will have NO effect on any other Tornado competition outside of China.. BECAUSE they will only race in 5 knotts and up. From my point of view... the best in the world recognize that weight matters and so to maintain a broad level of competition they will adjust the rules.... Notice.. No heavyweights are doing well in the T class... you better get to the optimum weight or no amount of skill will save you! This class is not TRYING to appeal to a large portion of the sailing public.. contrast that with F18's which have a large and small sail program for teams of very different weights. So, two different games and both are fair! Hmmm..... Gee, when the Clubs and Portsmouth committe try to generate as level a playing field as possible for as many sailors as possible by using the wind speed adjustment in handicap racing... will the volume of screaming decrease? (Not a chance!) Will weight adjustments be allowed for the Alter cup qualifiers? (Yes... they should be!) Should equipment changes which increase the performance but may not be properly factored into the rating be allowed at alter cup qualifiers? (No, too much room for playing the rules and possible loopholes here.) Should single one off boats have Portsmouth ratings (since the results of a single skipper determine the boats ratings... its essentially a personal handicap) (NO! see caveat) Should these one off boats get a measurement rating which is then scaled into the portmsouth ratings so that they can race and compete in the Alter qualifiers? (Yes!... when they get a class of boats together and hold a set number of events.... they can go be treated like any other PN class!) How is that for a thread hijack... Back on point... My point is... the rules are set up by US so that WE GET A FAIR PLAYING FIELD. and they are transparent enough so nobody has an ax to grind about politics... or an advantage through some super duper technology that only an elite group of sailors get access to (see last olympics cluster !@#$$%). So far... the T class and the F18 class have BANNED super duper sail materials (solves one problem from last olympics) They replaced the opportunity for custom alu masts (read $$$$) with an ISAF mandated Best manufacturing process mast program where EVERY MAST MADE is serial numbered and the Bend characteristics are measured for each stick andthese nubmers are published for the public to view (see www.tornado.org) (solves 2nd problem from last olympics) Now they are joining the F18 class by legislating a min team weight but still keeping their wind minimum for all events besides china (which they have no control over) Seems fair to the majority of sailors in the class to me! It would be silly to generate a group of T cat sailors who tip the scales at weights that the junior sailors compete at. Waiting for Dave I and Mary with flame suit on!
crac.sailregattas.com
| | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: Mark Schneider]
#99132 02/21/07 05:00 AM 02/21/07 05:00 AM |
Joined: Nov 2002 Posts: 5,558 Key Largo, FL & Put-in-Bay, OH... Mary
Carpal Tunnel
|
Carpal Tunnel
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 5,558 Key Largo, FL & Put-in-Bay, OH... | Mark, I guess some of us do not have the advantage of knowing how the actual ballot is worded. The original proposal says, "A minimum crew weight rule would protect the class from excessive crew manipulation at major championships that are held at very light air venues."
From that I assumed that this minimum crew weight would be a permanent part of the Tornado Class rules, just as it is for the Hobies and Nacras and Prindles and other classes.
But if it is just a change that only is in effect for major events where the 5-knot-minimum wind rule is not going to be enforced (and the sailing instructions say so), it would indeed make sense to have a minimum weight rule to counterbalance the wind rule change.
So, if that is the case, is there a provision for adding weights to the underweight boats for that particular event? And how much weight will be allowed to be added?
Is the Tornado the ONLY class that is asking for a minimum crew weight limit for the Olympics in Quindao?
I fully realize that this is a decision to be made by the class (and ISAF), and it is really no business of us non-Tornado-sailors. Except for the fact that our Olympic classes represent our countries, so the rest of the sailing community DOES feel involved to some extent in decisions that may affect one of our Olympic classes -- especially one that is open to women as well as men. | | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: Rolf_Nilsen]
#99135 02/22/07 02:36 PM 02/22/07 02:36 PM |
Joined: Jul 2006 Posts: 1,147 Bay of Islands, NZ warbird
old hand
|
old hand
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 1,147 Bay of Islands, NZ | I notice that the quotes from the F18 crews include the comment by the #2 boat includes the fact that they are quicker than The B&D show in heavier air because they have more weight and can drive through the heavy seas. Maybe the weight for the F18 is set wrong. B&D could be cut out of the comp with some more sensible weight ideas. B y the way, nobody answered e on the weights for lgith crew idea. IF heavier crews have an advantage in heavy air would it not be fair to have a top weight rule in heavy air comps? By the way.. what is the perfect "acceptable" weight?
Last edited by warbird; 02/22/07 02:39 PM.
| | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: warbird]
#99136 02/22/07 03:20 PM 02/22/07 03:20 PM |
Joined: Nov 2006 Posts: 404 Chattanooga, TN Joanna
addict
|
addict
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 404 Chattanooga, TN | Just wanted to add that my skipper and I are changing boats (H20 to a F16) just to be in a class with no minimum crew weight. We are 265lbs together with all our gear on. Carrying weight and having a heavy boat is just too much (and dangerous). We are not Olympic material but really enjoy racing. So I can vouch for teams that are lightweights and can't gain weight. If the class has not had a minimum crew weight in the past they really shouldn't add it now.
Joanna
Blade F16 "Too Sharp to Touch" | | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: warbird]
#99137 02/22/07 03:26 PM 02/22/07 03:26 PM |
Joined: Jun 2001 Posts: 3,116 Annapolis, MD Mark Schneider
Carpal Tunnel
|
Carpal Tunnel
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 3,116 Annapolis, MD | Rolf is absolutely correct about the national sailing authorities.
The sailing federation could care less about the team... they only care about winning a medal. .... Once the country has qualified... eg one of the teams finishes high enough in the world's Grade one and two events to secure one of the 20 slots allocated to Tornados .... the sailing federation could send whomever they wish to the Olympics. They do not even have to send they’re "top team". So, nothing would stop a country.... especially a country with a lower ranked and back of the fleet team to take that helm, roll the dice and create a new team with one new member weighing in at 70 lbs if they thought it would get them a medal.... In fact... it would be the smart thing to do!
Remember, they have the same discretion as the Gymnastics or Ice Skating federations... (For example the USA sailors might remember that Michelle Kwan was given a slot at the last Olympics based on her past accomplishments in ice skating. ... no worries about the competitor who finished third!).
By voting against the proposal, you shift MORE power to the Sailing Federations and TAKE power away from the sailors in the Class who are competing for the Olympic competition. For USA Sailors... do you really want to give Gary Bodie the opportunity to "COACH"... ???
(remeber this is the guy... who failed to discern that Kelly Jason was a GIRL entered into A MEN'S ONLY F18 ISAF competition and peform the proper due dillegence to make sure she had a waiver (or not...), but the other GIRL in the competition when informed that she could not helm with two X chromsomes withdrew and that was that.)
For the rank and file sailors, this class rule has no relevance... This is simply for the China Olympics and effects only the sailors who compete at the international level. By passing the weight minimum, the Class can preserve some integrity in the Olympic game by simply passing the min weight rule.
The hand wringing about the fairness to the featherweight sailors, etc, etc is not the essential issue.
Mark
crac.sailregattas.com
| | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: Mark Schneider]
#99138 02/22/07 04:31 PM 02/22/07 04:31 PM |
Joined: Dec 2001 Posts: 5,590 Naples, FL waterbug_wpb
Carpal Tunnel
|
Carpal Tunnel
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 5,590 Naples, FL | As an aside, are there any female teams in the Olympic tornado competition?
Jay
| | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: waterbug_wpb]
#99139 02/22/07 04:42 PM 02/22/07 04:42 PM |
Joined: Jun 2001 Posts: 3,116 Annapolis, MD Mark Schneider
Carpal Tunnel
|
Carpal Tunnel
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 3,116 Annapolis, MD | Sure.. Carolijn Brower (sp) from Belgium is a top 20 helm.... and curretly top 5 in the F18's down under. Obviously.... she is really good!
crac.sailregattas.com
| | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: waterbug_wpb]
#99140 02/22/07 04:46 PM 02/22/07 04:46 PM |
Joined: Jul 2001 Posts: 1,200 Vancouver, BC Tornado
veteran
|
veteran
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 1,200 Vancouver, BC | No all female teams as far as I know...but there are a few boy/girl teams.
Mike Dobbs Tornado CAN 99 "Full Tilt"
| | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: Tornado]
#99141 02/22/07 04:51 PM 02/22/07 04:51 PM |
Joined: Dec 2001 Posts: 5,590 Naples, FL waterbug_wpb
Carpal Tunnel
|
Carpal Tunnel
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 5,590 Naples, FL | That's what I was asking (all female teams). Thanks!
This entire class is so far above my ability level, it's hard to imagine...
Jay
| | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: waterbug_wpb]
#99142 02/22/07 06:09 PM 02/22/07 06:09 PM |
Joined: Jan 2004 Posts: 1,884 Detroit, MI mbounds
Pooh-Bah
|
Pooh-Bah
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 1,884 Detroit, MI | For USA Sailors... do you really want to give Gary Bodie the opportunity to "COACH"... ??? A long, long time ago in galaxy far, far away . . . Gary Bodie used to race Hobie 16s. I know. I was there. | | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: Mark Schneider]
#99143 02/22/07 06:42 PM 02/22/07 06:42 PM |
Joined: Nov 2002 Posts: 5,558 Key Largo, FL & Put-in-Bay, OH... Mary
Carpal Tunnel
|
Carpal Tunnel
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 5,558 Key Largo, FL & Put-in-Bay, OH... | Mark, I still have the question: If a minimum crew weight is approved for the 2008 Olympics, will underweight crews be allowed to add weights to the boat?....and, if so, what will be the maximum amount of weight they are allowed to add? | | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: Mary]
#99146 02/23/07 08:03 AM 02/23/07 08:03 AM |
Joined: Dec 2001 Posts: 5,590 Naples, FL waterbug_wpb
Carpal Tunnel
|
Carpal Tunnel
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 5,590 Naples, FL | Probably a bit of both. Imagine trying to catch a wayward T boat with an extra 10lbs of lead weight in your gear....
Jay
| | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: waterbug_wpb]
#99147 02/23/07 08:30 AM 02/23/07 08:30 AM |
Joined: Jan 2004 Posts: 1,884 Detroit, MI mbounds
Pooh-Bah
|
Pooh-Bah
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 1,884 Detroit, MI | It's a Racing Rules of Sailing issue: 43 COMPETITOR CLOTHING AND EQUIPMENT 43.1 (a) Competitors shall not wear or carry clothing or equipment for the purpose of increasing their weight. | | | Re: Fair and Level playing field wanted!
[Re: mbounds]
#99148 02/23/07 09:47 AM 02/23/07 09:47 AM |
Joined: Nov 2002 Posts: 5,558 Key Largo, FL & Put-in-Bay, OH... Mary
Carpal Tunnel
|
Carpal Tunnel
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 5,558 Key Largo, FL & Put-in-Bay, OH... | It's a Racing Rules of Sailing issue: 43 COMPETITOR CLOTHING AND EQUIPMENT 43.1 (a) Competitors shall not wear or carry clothing or equipment for the purpose of increasing their weight. But that still begs the question of "why". | | |
|
0 registered members (),
126
guests, and 83
spiders. | Key: Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod | | Forums26 Topics22,405 Posts267,059 Members8,150 | Most Online2,167 Dec 19th, 2022 | | |