I like fingerless gloves best and also have used Harken Black magic's forever.

I have two pairs, one pair is 8 years old has survived 5 NAC's and one Worlds in addition to countless weekend regatta's.

They are worn and look ratty as all billy hell.

The other pair lives in my gear bag as spares, for when I finally give up on the old ones.

At this point, its become almost a joke with myself, trying to see how long I can make the original pair of black Majic's last.

I've tried others, but If I had to go and buy a new pair today, I would get more of the same. My thought is why spend money trying to replace something I already know I like.
Disclaimer: I can be a bit of a Dinosaur, I still love sailing the Original Hobie 18.