I don't see a issue either way. (And I have read through the posts.)

One group wanted a level playing field for the reasons Matt B states: Nor did I want to deal with measuring sails. Another group opts for tweaks. So both went in different directions.

There is really nothing else that can be added to that that is not begging the question.

All of the recent discussions about regatta problems is simply about problems of communication.

As a new person to racing, nothing turns me off more than having information about the regattas confused and poorly laid out. THIS is what's wrong. If you can't say it succinctly for everyone to get quickly and understand clearly then continue to expect what you are getting for regatta attendance...

Really the end of the story.