I'm satisfied with my understanding of the rules. I've never hit anyone and never been protested, iirc. Do I engage in "gamesmanship" occassionally? Yes.

Have I been blatantly fouled by sailors who should have known better? ABSOLUTELY! And there are is at least one witness who posts here daily.

I have a concern about the current rules and I've identified a simple remedy. I have passed along both to an officer of my class. Will any action be taken? I've no idea but I'm satisified I've done my part in making sailing a little better.

My objection to the ad hominem fallacy stands. We'd have been better off without it.